Welcome to Tony's N.Y. Pizza
Tony's N.Y. Pizza, located in Fort Myers, Florida, offers a slice of authentic New York-style pizza that delights both locals and visitors. With a focus on thin, crispy crusts and perfectly balanced sauce, their offerings leave pizza lovers, like Joseph Hogan, thoroughly satisfied. The menu features standout items, including amazing calzones and savory meatball Parm, complemented by friendly service from staff member Judith, who creates a warm atmosphere. Customers rave about the garlic knots and specialty dishes like the Queens White pizza. Whether you're looking for a quick lunch or a cozy dinner, Tony's is a must-try for pizza aficionados.
Tony's N.Y. Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Amazing Calzones . Great place to have lunch and enjoy some Sinatra songs
Their pizza is awesome. Coming from NJ but living here in Ft Myers for 19 years I’m always on a search for good pizza and I found it here. They hit on all 3 ; the crust is thin and crispy the sauce is great tasting and amount is perfect the cheese is a perfect melt and taste. Compliments to the pie maker. You do it right! They make great meatballs too. The meatball parm is awesome. And JUDITH!!! You can’t get anyone nicer and more accommodating. She really makes you feel welcome. Judith is someone special and they’re fortunate to have her. Try it here. You won’t be disappointed
Vacationing in ft myers from Michigan. My hubby was born and raised on Long Island/Queens and is ALWAYS looking for NY pizza!! Came across Tony's NY pizza, and ordered a pie and garlic knots. Hubby was doing the happy dance!! The pizza is so close to the real deal!! The crust was amazing!! Might have to take a couple pies back home to Michigan! The garlic knots we close, but definitely needed more garlic.
I've been there on several occasions and was never disappointed by their offerings. All that I've had has been absolutely top shelf. Would most definitely recommend over anybody else.
I can't speak on atmosphere because I'm stuck at home with a broken leg. I did doorgrubdelivery whatever and got a stromboli and The Queens White pizza. This stuff is so really good. The food is so tasty it made me forget about my broken bones.Haven't even tried the cheese cake yet but I'm sure that's going to be delicious too! Killer grub! Good stuff! Thanks yall! Order from these folks! Worth every penny
Had great service from the staff. There was a family celebrating a birthday sitting outside, I joked with them about having some dessert with them, low and behold, they insisted we have a piece of chocolate cheesecake. It was excellent and the laughs we shared with them were priceless. We'll be back!
We brought my dad here who just moved from NY. Best pizza in Fort Myers! Best items we had were the Sicilian, eggplant pizza and garlic knots. Staff was super friendly and efficient! Will be back soon!
Krissy provided me with the best service. I needed a pie delivered to my wife’s b-day party as a surprise. Krissy went above and beyond to help me surprise my wife. This was 1st rate customer service. My wife and I have eaten Tony’s food several times, and we love it. Classic NY-style pizzeria.
Location
-
6900 Daniels Pkwy #3, Fort Myers, FL 33912, United States Hotline: +1 239-362-0604
If you're searching for authentic New York pizza in Fort Myers, look no further than Tony's N.Y. Pizza. Located conveniently at 6900 Daniels Pkwy #3, Fort Myers, FL, this pizzeria has quickly won the hearts of locals and visitors alike. With a simple phone call to +1 239-362-0604, you can dive into a world of flavors that transport you straight to the bustling streets of New York City.
The praise for Tony's N.Y. Pizza is abundant, and rightly so. Customers rave about the thin and crispy crust, the rich and flavorful sauce, and the perfect melt of cheese. Joseph Hogan, a self-proclaimed pizza aficionado, emphasizes that this pizza is legit, saying, "They hit on all 3," showcasing that Tony's understands the elements of a classic New York pie. Their compliment-worthy meatball parm is another highlight that has captivated the taste buds of many.
One of the standout features of Tony's N.Y. Pizza is their timely service. Judith, a friendly face behind the counter, has garnered affection from patrons for her warm hospitality, making everyone feel welcome. “You can’t get anyone nicer and more accommodating,” shares Joseph, underscoring that great service pairs perfectly with great food.
The menu doesn't stop at pizza. The calzones are also a crowd-pleaser, earning high praise from Iddy Garcia, who describes them as amazing and perfect for a lunch break accompanied by the soothing sounds of Sinatra. In addition, the garlic knots are a must-try, though some suggest they could use extra garlic for that authentic kick.
Whether you're a local or a traveler, a visit to Tony's N.Y. Pizza is a must. As Sonya Bracco remarked, the pizza was so realistic that it had her husband doing the "happy dance." This is a place where you can enjoy comforting, delicious food that makes you feel at home even if you're thousands of miles away. With offerings like the Queens White pizza and generous stromboli, there's no doubt that Tony's has something for everyone.
So why not indulge in a slice (or two) at Tony's N.Y. Pizza? It's more than just a meal—it's an experience worth savoring. Don't just take my word for it; the community has spoken, and Tony's is surely delivering every time.